Install Raid for Free ✅ Mobile or PC: clik.cc/MrfQ0 and get a special starter pack 💥Available only for the next 30 days!

john doe

2 dni temu

once its was a meme, now its a real game O.o

JudeMcDude

17 dni temu

No

Mark Peterson

Miesiąc temu

The CGI looked bad because Favreau had to do it in one day in secret by just 2 people. To keep it from leaking and keep it from Kathleen Kennedy.

Kohakka Nuva

Miesiąc temu

NO

shperax

Miesiąc temu

People are pretty critical here, but over all your version is better then Disney. It moves way more realistic.

Not so really good but better

That's not better! Is that a joke?

I love you guys but the orig looks more realistic yours looks creepy

I nearly cried, that’s incredible guys

I can’t believe you managed you pull it off

Next time use a neopixel lightsaber the lighting would have looked way more intense

You are better

Amazing how a company of billions did a worse job than you... It almost angers me.

It's a fine recreation but it lacks five years of ageing and calmness that comes with the experience.

Wow this was much better than the official one. Great job! 👍🏼

You ALL KILLED IT!!

I'm sorry but both look weird

I'm glad to know your channel, for me it's a masterpiece, I can't even imagine the end like this, overwhelming! such a belleza. I love so much

Why didnt disney just hire sebastian stan as luke he looks so much like mark hamil

Your Luke looked like Anakin I love it thanks

The final result looks amazing! I really love it. Good job!!

I can say... Amazing work! Dream team!

No.

6/10

Much more believable visuals... but somehow... worse acting than Mark Hamill. How is that possible?

Anyone else thinking that M. Hamill looks CGIsh in the original trilogy takes?

It was good 👍😌👌👏☺😊

Rogue One and Furious 7 are switched, nice!

The ADR is slightly off in the final line, "May the force be with you". Honestly though, we are looking for it. 99% of all views wouldn't even know. Good job.

Too much movements.

Disney do average job still look too plastic PC game like for money involved

Just a pleasant shout-out: I'm watching this on a Puget Systems PC, with which I am very happy.

Better than Multi-billion dollar CGI lol

the "spoiler alert" in the video is moot cos of the title and thumbnail.

As far as him really looking like luke the face looks fantastic yea we know you kinda threw it together quick and the hair not great but The Face overall way way better 100%

you know he is not the same age right?

With all that incredible and expensive digital tech at their disposal, complete and unrestricted access to hardware and facilities. With all those endless hours spent layering imaging and modelling at no doubt 60fps.... for that super smooth hyper-realistic effect. We all know REAL isn't enough anymore (24-30fps), they still couldn't write some decent inspired dialogue? Every second of it clangs, to the point where you think they did it on purpose. How many more times do we need to see people re-imagine, remake & piss on other people's work? Once again this proves that everything starts with the script. I'm not easily pleased like some people, it is transparent. For the most part, this is why storytelling is dead in the water. Write intelligently, originally and thoughtfully before you embark on any passion project. If it doesn't engage the people around you, your friends and family for instance, it's not going to entertain the masses. Test audiences are a great tool for refining your work, unbiased opinions are what you should be seeking. For good writing all you need is a pen and paper, and a brain. Isn't that just great? And it costs nothing but time. For the record I think the Disney version of Luke is better.

I don't think you know what the word better means

The hair is so bad, i have to go with the original 😊

Anyone else notice the 'Furious 7' and 'Rouge One' mistake

The fact I know crap about cgi but it just made me mad how they didn't use Mark fot this... Like... ?¿

Wow. That was utterly terrible All the talk and tech and it looked worse.

thinking of two films where there are janky head replacements, you could review The Comeback Trail, scene just after the horse jumped over some flames (53:51), Tommy Lee Jones' head looks super fake. And similarly, there's a scene in I, Tonya where Margot Robbie is doing pirouettes on ice (wearing turquoise outfit) and the head replacements just stands out so much in some shots

Please for a react of the Old Republic Game cut scenes. The one where the mother is trying to save her daughter is amazing.

I do agree that the first luke was kind of like looking at a freestanding, lifesize toy of Luke. So this variant, with the eyes and the smile and the eyes and neck movement... and did I mention the eyes?... Very well done guys. :)

Pretty good for 2 weeks, but.... Disney's was better!

you did the spiler alert after you showed the scene wow you guys are absolut geniuses

i think its better and that even with the disadvantage of doing this third party after the movie was made.

18:22-18:24 WHOOOOOOOOA!

If you had just fixed the hair, it would have ben perfect. But, hands down SOOO much better than the actual show's version!

that's sick

The lip sync doesn't work that well

Pffft. Yeah right.

This CGi on Hamil is really cool

I won't even get fooled by that deepfake of Tom Cruise.

Well mandalorian luke needs to look 7 years older than ROTJ luke.

imagine what you guys could do on a Disney budget

Next do the last fight black panther fight scene.

Disneys is better

Disney should have just gotten Sebastian Stan to put on a little makeup, ready for a Skywalker spin-off series.

Thanks for the spoiler alert. I’ll be back in a couple weeks.

Amazing what you guys did in such a short time!

More detailed Deepfake

This is LIT.

Why are ppl saying its better, it looks way more unreal and fake.

Instead a RTX 3090, an FPGA should do a better job, isn't?

The neck and facial expressions weren’t quite as good. I guess this approach works for people that are no longer with us, but if you have the living actor or one of their kids, it would be a better base to superimpose the younger face over top of. See if you can deep fake Carrie Fisher over top of her daughter Billie to see how that works, or deep fake someone from 30 years ago on top of their current day self, because I’d bet that with the geometry of the facial structures being so much closer that the AI won’t have to work as hard to figure out what’s in between the two images.

It's better and worse. I like the movements and that an improvement. Disney's, though stiff, looked a bit more life like.

Honestly this is way better. I laughed for a solid 30 seconds when I saw Luke appear. It was the same reaction with Tarkin. I said "wow as long as he doesn't take his hood off this will be really cool" and then it happened

the face is more tan than the neck that messes it up

1. What was the thing with the fingers? Ugh..... 2. The last scene was bad, the face looked very glossy... :( But other than that yeah, you did a better job! Guess a few billions weren't enough... lol

Looked amazing way more realistic than disneys

No non lo trovo migliore

I think it is a push. You guys made something that definitely feels more alive, but I feel like Disney having the time and resources they did made something that looked a bit crisper and more tangible.

unbelievable...

The "uncanny" part of this video was the mouth tracking, I find that to be a common problem with CGI and de-aging too (TRON Legacy). A mouth that moves more expressively and tracks tighter to words can help sell otherwise flawed footage.

Disney should hire you guys.

The worst thing in the scene is how bad the Yoda toy was.

Very nice job!

17:28

Why doesn't Disney just hire these guys?

when will you guys learn to step up your wig game? ^^

Lukes good :)

Just speaking from my own perspective and own opinion. I'm not in any position to criticize, this is just my own personal opinion and perspective. About your guy's version: Cons: Luke is a little too skinny. Pros: Everything. Everything else is perfect in my opinion. The features look just like Mark Hamill. In comparison to the original: Your version is way better. Also thank you for giving us this video. :) Subscribed.

nice but mouth movement is still off

wow man luke is really good.

its the hair it looks so bad with the hair

Your version looks better in my opinion, great job! Subscribed!

At times I could see a laser-sharp line between Luke's face and Dean's forehead, but other than that it was perfect.

hmm. i think it was more of a side-step rather than an improvement.

It’s prime time now. Josh Hutcherson is 28. Dax Shepard, the guy who played an older version of the character, was 29 when they filmed zathura. Make it happen!!!

Eh I mean tbh the forehead triangle part was weird.

They could have just hired Sebastian Stan. Instant younger lookalike for Mark Hamil without any needed VFX. ;) But it's super interesting to see how you do this.

Ending clapping bit was a bit foot loose.

There's more detail, the lighting is better, the eyes look better. It's a solid attempt. I still wouldn't call it good, but it's improved for sure. Something about the mouth and head movement feels off. It also looks a bit too much like video game cgi.

It's better cgi, but it looks worse. FeelsBadMan

i dont think yours is any better honestly

You really didn’t

I mean he is supposed to be like 5-10 years older here so...

Quality goes to Disney Realism goes to you

Looks good but looks like EA Battlefronts

Don’t you agree that they should consider making a video with a deep fake and put dean on falcon and the winter soldier?

i see why this was made but the reason the original looks a little different from the luke in the OT is because hes grown older since then, great vid though.

IMHO your version achieve a better dinamic light over the face and that is very hard to accomplish, congrats!